Metheny distributed the falsified helicopter weight and balance charts, as well as other falsified FAA helicopter performance charts to pilots and helicopter flight manuals for use in the field. Unaware of the false nature of the charts, they were then used by pilots and the Forest Service personnel in conducting wildfire flight operations. Their use included calculating the helicopter’s maximum payload capacity during firefighting operations thereby risking the life and safety of the pilots operating the helicopters and those aboard, including firefighters.

On August 5, 2008, N612AZ crashed during takeoff while conducting firefighting operations. The crash resulted in nine fatalities and four were severely injured. The pilots utilized these same falsified charts in the flight manual in determining the payload calculations for the fatal flight.

The surviving and permanently injured co-pilot of N612AZ said that pilots trust the integrity of the charts with their life; if the weight of the helicopter is wrong, the final payload will be wrong. If he had known, he would never have used those charts. Other pilots also stressed the importance of using accurate charts as an integral part to the safe operation of a helicopter, especially when carrying passengers. If the Forest Service manager at the crash site had known the truth about the falsified weight documents, the operation would have been immediately shut down and the firefighters would not have been allowed on board the helicopter.

National Transportation Safety Board (NTSB) investigators would later discover the accurate weight documents for the crash helicopter and learn that it weighed over 1400 lbs. more than the falsified weight documents used by the pilots. Within days of the crash, Metheny replaced the crash helicopter with another helicopter for the contract by using falsified FAA power performance charts and weight documents for that aircraft.

Court documents further disclose that following the crash of N612AZ, Metheny and Phillips then attempted to conceal the fraud by devising schemes to prevent the Forest Service from discovering the actual weight of each aircraft under contract. Their schemes included having Carson pilots and crew improperly remove equipment and helicopter components without recording their removal.

However, some refused and one crew chief explained that he was done lying about the helicopter’s weight. The Forest Service eventually discovered that all of the aircraft were over their bid weight, the weight documents submitted in the contract proposals were fraudulent with underreported weights and the helicopters were using falsified performance charts. All of the contracts were terminated.

Government documents show that Metheny also concealed the fraudulent conduct involving N612AZ from the NTSB during its crash investigation. He and Phillips were Carson representatives on the NTSB investigation. Yet, Metheny knew NTSB investigators were relying on the falsified weight documents used by the crash helicopter and he attempted to convince them of their accuracy.

Later, when NTSB discovered that the performance chart used by N612AZ was falsified, the product of a “cut and paste” created at Carson’s Grants Pass office, Metheny attempted to throw suspicion onto a former employee, someone he held animosity toward.

Court documents further reveal that Metheny was continuously stealing from Carson. He used Carson funds to buy jewelry and other personal items for himself and his wife, to renovate their residence and he sold Carson helicopter parts and equipment and diverted the proceeds to his own private aviation company for his personal use. He also stole tail rotor blades from a shipment at Carson’s Grants Pass facility then attempted again to place suspicion on the same person he had animosity toward. Metheny repaid Carson over $73,900 as restitution for the theft of helicopter parts from the company.

In recommending a sentence of 15.5 years, Assistant U.S. Attorney Chatfield argued Metheny was the architect behind the scheme to defraud the Forest Service and gain a significant advantage over his competitors. His fraudulent conduct was the result of pure greed that eventually placed the lives of numerous pilots and firefighters in extreme danger. Metheny demonstrated such an indifference to the danger in which he placed others just to perpetuate the fraud. As a licensed helicopter pilot, he knew the falsified charts put firefighters and pilots at risk of serious injury, even death. 

Chatfield said that helicopter firefighting operations certainly have a high level of risk where failure can have catastrophic consequences, such as with the crash of N612AZ. Yet, what is totally unacceptable is the substantial risk Metheny created by his fraudulent conduct, unnecessarily putting the lives of so many pilots and firefighters in harm’s way. 

Metheny’s conduct has had such an adverse and lasting impact on so many people, both financially and emotionally. To know that those firefighters who lost their lives would not have been even allowed on the crash helicopter if the Forest Service manager or the pilots had known about the falsified weight is absolutely devastating to their families.

“This is an incredibly disturbing case that has exposed the senseless greed behind this despicable criminal conduct. There is a price to pay for submitting false information about helicopter payload capabilities in the bid process. The intentional deceit defrauded the Forest Service and created a reckless risk of harm to those who used the information in firefighting operations, including those who were relying on the false information when a Carson helicopter crashed near Weaverville, California on August 5, 2008,” says Acting U.S. Attorney, Billy J. Williams. “The lives of heroic individuals serving in these operations were placed in harm’s way when greedy people enriched their pockets without consideration for their conduct.”